Review: 21362 Mineral Collection
Posted by Huw,
Dario Del Frate's LEGO Ideas project Minerals Display, which passed review in November 2024, proposed six mineral samples displayed on shelves and that's exactly what the finished model, 21362 Mineral Collection, has delivered, less than a year later.
However, there have been changes which, hopefully, have improved rather than impaired it.
Summary
21362 Mineral Collection, 880 pieces.
£54.99 / $59.99 / €59.99 | 6.2p/6.8c/6.8c per piece.
Buy at LEGO.com »
Interesting, colourful, attractive, and unlike anything LEGO has made before
- Intricate and detailed specimens
- Faithful to the original Ideas submission
- Separate shelf sections necessitate care when handling
The set was provided for review by LEGO. All opinions expressed are those of the author.
This is Dario's winning submission, which is actually his second minerals-themed one to achieve the requisite number of supporters on the Ideas platform.
The main difference between it and the set is the selection of minerals included, and their finesse.
The project proposed samples of rhodochrosite, amethyst, black tourmaline, orange quartz, emerald, and pyrite. Some have been carried over (rhodochrosite, amethyst, pyrite, quartz), one has been changed (tourmaline is now watermelon rather than black), and the emerald has been replaced with fluorite.
It's still an excellent and varied selection in terms of shape, form, and colour.
The overall design of the tiered shelving unit remains the same but, rather than being one piece, it comprises three separate unconnected sections designed to be butted against each other.
In his project, Dario states that "the case can be hung directly to a wall or simply put on a shelf" but, as it is, it would not be possible to hang this one without some modification, and you need to bear in mind that it's in sections when picking it up.
The shelves are 'glass', but due to the need to include a stud on them upon which to attach the stones, they have a 'wood' strip down the centre which spoils the look of them a bit.
Watermelon Tourmaline
This beautiful crystal has a pink core surrounded by green which gives it its name.
The colour transition in the model has been created with pink and green pieces in the centre, a layer of trans-yellow plates around them, then transparent elements on the sides. It's quite effective although arguably the two layers of transparent pieces have subdued the effect somewhat.
Pyrite
This fools gold sample utilises drum-lacquered gold pieces, including what I believe are Minecraft heads. They have certainly helped create a realistic shape and texture.
Amethyst
The amethyst geode is much bigger than that in the Ideas submission, and I think it looks very life-like. I particularly like the colour transition effect that the pink tiles behind the transparent pieces around the edges have created.
Just like real ones, the back just looks like a rock.
Rhodochrosite
This sample is the most complex in terms of design, with stud-reversal techniques incorporated into the base to allow the transparent handles to stick out upwards, and hinges angling the red crystals to create an organic and realistic appearance.
Tangerine Quartz
A coating of iron oxide gives this mineral its colour, and in this sample, trans-orange, yellow and clear cheese slopes attached to a core of trans-orange SNOT bricks create a pleasing colour transition from the base to the tip of the large hexagonal crystal.
A couple of smaller square ones jut out at angles from the rocky base, once again creating a very realistic appearance.
Fluorite
This colourful specimen uses four of this new 4x4 corner slope piece that can also be found in the Black Pearl, in black of course.
Once again, the use of transparent parts around a contrasting colour core, in this case green, has produced an interesting colour transition.
Verdict
The mineral samples are realistic and life-sized which, like the best models of real-life objects, could be mistaken for the real thing from a distance. They are intricate and slightly fiddly to build, involving many small pieces and studs in all directions, but the effort is worth it.
It could be said that the set is more shelf than minerals, and that is certainly true in terms of volume of plastic, but without the shelves the set would just be a disparate collection of small models rather than a cohesive whole.
Changes between the Ideas submission and the set are minimal, which is testament to the quality of Dario's original model. That which has been altered -- the mineral selection and the finesse of the samples -- has only improved it.
This is exactly the sort of set that would not exist without the Ideas platform. It's like nothing LEGO has produced before, and I like it.
148 likes
59 comments on this article
I actually think he did a better job with the geode than LEGO did.
I don't know. This just looks disappointing to me and therefore will pass.
I choose to consider this the first official Breaking Bad set.
I prefer the original geode's shape, but prefer the new one's colour scheme.
Might pick it up soon, I think it will look nice next to 21313 on my shelf.
I really like the LEGO version! :)
Typo: Fl_uo_rite is the correct spelling.
Someones gonna mod this into a kyber crystal display. I'm calling it. 100% Guaranteed.
Nice! I do still like the minerals from the original design a bit better, but as a whole it still looks great. And in the earlier pictures I hadn't noticed the "glass" shelves, I actually like those!
And indeed this is Ideas at its best. Maybe not a set for everyone (but at least Ruri approves!), but indeed one that truly wouldn't have existed otherwise. Considering the number of sets I have yet to build and even more the lack of display space this is not that high on my priority list, but will likely get it some day.
Absolutely love this. Definitely a day 1 purchase, half decent GWP willing. And, of course, it could have an unsuspicious secondary use as a handy murder weapon!
I don't know if this is necessarily my thing, purchase-wise, but all the rocks look really nice.
I mentioned this before and here it is again: there should be plaques with name and composition for each of them. This would render this set quite educational. And then, you could remove all the rocks and ask your friends to put them back where they believe they belong. It is quite niche, it is reasonably well rendered but still quite niche. Hopefully for the designer, it will do well.
@ohrmazd said:
"I actually think he did a better job with the geode than LEGO did."
Same.
As a former mineral collector myself, I find the final version of the amethyst very much inferior to the original submission. The pyrite is definitely better on the final product though.
I still think that just six printed 1x8 tiles with the mineral names (and chemical formulae) on a SNOT brick are necessary to make this look good.
I assume they changed the shape of the amethyst to make it more like an upscaled version of the Lego geode piece? I kind of like that.
@ohrmazd said:
"I actually think he did a better job with the geode than LEGO did."
I have to agree, the original submission for the most part seemed more realistic and somehow also more elegant, especially the geode, and the shelves were better designed as well if they could be hung up. I understand probably the original black tourmaline used an illegal technique (?), but it looks fascinating. The trans-clear parts in the Lego version don't do it for me.
I’ll wait for animal and vegetable then make a choice.
I have a few rocks on a shelf, and this would look nice behind them!
Plus I just like the look of that geode.
I maybe in the minority, but I liked the original geode and black tourmaline better.
However, swapping out the emerald was a good idea.
I will pick this up when I see it on sale.
Every day, we stray further from Khonshu.
Missed an opportunity to upscale part 4519318: ROCK CRYSTAL for this set
“This colourful specimen uses four of this new 4x4 corner slope piece that can also be found in the Black Pearl, in black of course.”
What is this ‘Black Pearl’ you speak of ? Some other mineral?
@twentythree said:
"“This colourful specimen uses four of this new 4x4 corner slope piece that can also be found in the Black Pearl, in black of course.”
What is this ‘Black Pearl’ you speak of ? Some other mineral?
"
Wouldn't it be nice if you'd get a Bleack Pearl as GWP with this set?
A billionaire enjoys comission off insane PPP in sets.
A humble IDEAS winner? Set sold at half the going rate.
We don't actually know the numbers though I really do hope I'm wrong on this one!
@twentythree said:
"“This colourful specimen uses four of this new 4x4 corner slope piece that can also be found in the Black Pearl, in black of course.”
What is this ‘Black Pearl’ you speak of ? Some other mineral?"
he meant "Jack Sparrow's Pirate Mineral."
As a fan of all things fiction. Where is the kryptonite, adamantium and the ooze?
Ignoring the fact that regardless of size, both the quartz and tourmaline crystals should be six-sided prismatic with hexagonal pyramid or hexagonal terminations, this is an excellent representation of the minerals as well as the original IDEAS submission. Already pre-ordered. This set has of course caused some discussion on mineral collector related websites.
@emartinez said:
"As a fan of all things fiction. Where is the kryptonite, adamantium and the ooze? "
Right next to the Unobtanium!
I could not care less about that set, but both my 13 and 18 yo kids are into rocks and will get this set for Christmas. I know they'll like it.
I like this set a lot! I own a number of actual gemstones and crystals, so part of me is like "Just buy the real thing" but this is much cheaper and still very attractive.
I'll need to think of a place to display this, but this is definitely on my radar for the holiday season.
@CCC said:"I still think that just six printed 1x8 tiles with the mineral names (and chemical formulae) on a SNOT brick are necessary to make this look good."
I think that it already looks good, but I agree that those would improve it.
@WizardOfOss said:
" @emartinez said:
"As a fan of all things fiction. Where is the kryptonite, adamantium and the ooze? "
Right next to the Unobtanium!"
This is dilithium erasure.
I can imagine a Classic Space landscape with these incorporated into it!
It’s just so preeeetttyyyyy~
@WizardOfOss said:
" @twentythree said:
"“This colourful specimen uses four of this new 4x4 corner slope piece that can also be found in the Black Pearl, in black of course.”
What is this ‘Black Pearl’ you speak of ? Some other mineral?
"
Wouldn't it be nice if you'd get a Bleack Pearl as GWP with this set? "
30131 you called?
Make sure to never disassemble this set if plan to later reassemble it because you wouldn't want the transparent pieces to get scratched or dirty.
@Crux said:
"Every day, we stray further from Khonshu."
Lovely parts pack but it’s like a mystic plastic-crystal shop display:
Gold Pyrite: It’s nobody’s fool and will give enriching effects on your life if not your (wallet) also known as ‘comedy gold’...
Is it just me, or does the rhodochrosite look kinda like jelly cubes to anyone else...?
(picture for reference, because I don't think they exist in America? https://cdn.mos.cms.futurecdn.net/5DBXDkPNSrZQu4Eauy72Tf.jpg)
@watcher21 said:
" @WizardOfOss said:
" @twentythree said:
"“This colourful specimen uses four of this new 4x4 corner slope piece that can also be found in the Black Pearl, in black of course.”
What is this ‘Black Pearl’ you speak of ? Some other mineral?
"
Wouldn't it be nice if you'd get a Bleack Pearl as GWP with this set? "
30131 you called?"
That's not the black pearl we're looking for ;-)
@ThatBionicleGuy said:
"Is it just me, or does the rhodochrosite look kinda like jelly cubes to anyone else...?
(picture for reference, because I don't think they exist in America? https://cdn.mos.cms.futurecdn.net/5DBXDkPNSrZQu4Eauy72Tf.jpg)"
I don't know if anyone sells it in that exact configuration here, but I can confirm the pretty red Lego rock looks equally like delicious gelatin on this side of the Atlantic.
@Sepulchure said:
"A billionaire enjoys comission off insane PPP in sets.
A humble IDEAS winner? Set sold at half the going rate.
We don't actually know the numbers though I really do hope I'm wrong on this one!"
What a weird haiku.
This was a set that I didn’t really care about when it was approved. Yet, I actually really like it! I also like the set’s Geode. They both look good, but I think I prefer that one better. I think this could also be the next Tales of the Space Age set in the sense of building other things. I could have a whole Adventurer display too! I think that description tiles would’ve been quite cool, but I don’t mind the exclusion. It’s on the back burner, but I may have to pick this one up eventually. Definitely a nice set.
It would be nice to buy this set and then expand it with other minerals if only someone posted MOC instructions e.g. on Rebrickable.
@Father_Nathan said:
"It would be nice to buy this set and then expand it with other minerals if only someone posted MOC instructions e.g. on Rebrickable."
Or... you could just build them yourself? And then sell the plans on Rebrickable. And amass wealth, and power. And as you sit on your throne of gold, bricks and gold bricks, the world in your hand, you will remember this moment as your origin-story. Today is a big day, and I am very happy for you.
Original submission was WAY BETTER.
@Father_Nathan said:
"It would be nice to buy this set and then expand it with other minerals if only someone posted MOC instructions e.g. on Rebrickable."
Well, people have already started…
I would have been happy, if I had seej the chemical formula of the minerals.
Agreeing with the peanut gallery that the original horizontal geode was more appealing and that label plaques would have been nice. Still, I might pick this up - lots of nice transparent and metallic pieces, the transparent shelves allow for more light to come through and show off the rocks better, the slight size reduction from the submission allows it to fit at a more affordable price point for buyers, and the dormant itch of my third grade interest in geology and mineralogy is being scratched.
I can't help but think that this is essentially the botanical series, but for men. Not that men don't like the botanicals, I have a couple myself, it just feels like that's the sort of niche they're trying to target. Honestly, it's pretty nice.
A lot of people (myself included) think that this set would be improved with tiles bearing the names and/or chemical formulas of the minerals. If someone did stickers or custom prints as an addon, I wonder how well those would sell.
@legomaster65 said:
"I can't help but think that this is essentially the botanical series, but for men. Not that men don't like the botanicals, I have a couple myself, it just feels like that's the sort of niche they're trying to target. Honestly, it's pretty nice."
Star Wars is the botanical series for men. And also Icons, Ideas, Creator, City, Ninjago, Friends, Minecraft, Seasonal, lol.
@yellowcastle said:
" @legomaster65 said:
"I can't help but think that this is essentially the botanical series, but for men. Not that men don't like the botanicals, I have a couple myself, it just feels like that's the sort of niche they're trying to target. Honestly, it's pretty nice."
Star Wars is the botanical series for men. And also Icons, Ideas, Creator, City, Ninjago, Friends, Minecraft, Seasonal, lol."
I'm not sure there's someone out there who feels that they are too insecure about their masculinity to like plants, but still confident enough in their fandom for little sometimes-plant-based plastic bricks, but who at the same time can only express their love for those bricks if they're rearranged in rock-form BUT NOT PLANT-FORM, NEVER PLANT-FORM.
If you are that person, we can't be friends. I don't have the energy to deal with you, I barely have enough energy to deal with my own issues.
@Crux said:
" @yellowcastle said:
" @legomaster65 said:
"I can't help but think that this is essentially the botanical series, but for men. Not that men don't like the botanicals, I have a couple myself, it just feels like that's the sort of niche they're trying to target. Honestly, it's pretty nice."
Star Wars is the botanical series for men. And also Icons, Ideas, Creator, City, Ninjago, Friends, Minecraft, Seasonal, lol."
I'm not sure there's someone out there who feels that they are too insecure about their masculinity to like plants, but still confident enough in their fandom for little sometimes-plant-based plastic bricks, but who at the same time can only express their love for those bricks if they're rearranged in rock-form BUT NOT PLANT-FORM, NEVER PLANT-FORM.
If you are that person, we can't be friends. I don't have the energy to deal with you, I barely have enough energy to deal with my own issues."
Yes, you called? I'm here.
BTW, I showed up to that supposed birthday party of yours. There was no one there. It was just an empty warehouse! The guy sweeping the floor had never heard of you.
To the issue at hand, I like rocks.... and plants. I'm not sure I like rocks this much. Yet, the price seems pretty good. Also, I am persuaded by a lot of the comments proposing that these could be used as scenery in space-based/minifig layouts. I love the Botanicals that can be reused for the same purpose- like the bonsai.
I find the large Botanical flower displays to have become nuisance, part-shedding, dust collectiors especially with because they're in parts of my home exposed to forced air and cooking grease unlike the rest of my Lego.
Mrs. StyleCounselor has shown no interest after building them to dust them or keep the pieces from falling everywhere. In that sense, they're like real flowers. They're just a bit more expensive, and have taken a bit longer to wither, turn grey, and die.
Ah yes, women, notoriously totally disinterested in shiny rocks.
Not at all fond of collecting crystals.
what exactly is the appeal of displaying something like this lego as opposed to, you know, an *actual* mineral collection? I just don't get stuff like this at all.
I've been a fan of minerals for a long time. Dad was a geologist and had a really nice collection. I still collect minerals. I was super excited when I originally saw this was going to be produced and have been waiting for the official release. Interestingly, I have specimens for each of the minerals in this display. Maybe I will work up some way to display them together. I definitely prefer the more vertical version of amethyst as these towers seem to be the more common means of selling them (at least in my experience).
@n3y0 said:
"what exactly is the appeal of displaying something like this lego as opposed to, you know, an *actual* mineral collection? I just don't get stuff like this at all."
It's fun to see something that looks like one thing but is actually another, and it’s fun to see the clever techniques and part usage involved in pulling it off.
I prefer the original design but love them both and will certainly get this set. Totally different from any other Lego set, unique, colorful. Just the sort of creative set the Ideas theme should yield.
@legomaster65 said:
"I can't help but think that this is essentially the botanical series, but for men. Not that men don't like the botanicals, I have a couple myself, it just feels like that's the sort of niche they're trying to target. Honestly, it's pretty nice."
I know alot of women collecting gems like these solely for fun, me included.
@n3y0 said:
"what exactly is the appeal of displaying something like this lego as opposed to, you know, an *actual* mineral collection? I just don't get stuff like this at all."
I've already got a mineral collection made of minerals. One made of Lego would be a fun novelty. The Lego set is also cheaper than some real minerals.
@Hiratha said:
" @n3y0 said:
"what exactly is the appeal of displaying something like this lego as opposed to, you know, an *actual* mineral collection? I just don't get stuff like this at all."
It's fun to see something that looks like one thing but is actually another, and it’s fun to see the clever techniques and part usage involved in pulling it off."
It's also fun to see people's reaction. "That's made of Legos?" (Yes, they will say "Legos.")